Can you trust your Zestimate to price your Delaware home?
Not on its own. A Zestimate is a computer estimate built from public records and past sales, and it never sees the inside of your house. Zillow's own track record shows the limits: its CEO sold a Seattle home in 2016 for 40% less than the Zestimate shown the day after the sale, and in 2021 Zillow shut down its home-buying business after its pricing models overpaid for thousands of homes. Courts have agreed with Zillow that a Zestimate is only an estimate, not an appraisal. To price a home, use recent closed sales nearby and an in-person look at condition.
By David Sordelet | Nov 22, 2026
Myth: "Zillow says my house is worth $X, so that's what it's worth."
Fact: Even Zillow learned the hard way that an algorithm can't see what a buyer sees.
Last week I wrote about Zestimates vs. CMAs vs. appraisals and what Zillow's published accuracy numbers mean. This week is about the people on the other end of those numbers: the sellers, buyers, and agents who get frustrated when an online estimate and real life don't match. And about what Zillow itself went through.
Three moments that show the limits of online estimates
1. Zillow's own CEO sold below his Zestimate. In 2016, then-CEO Spencer Rascoff sold a Seattle home for $1.05 million. The day after the sale, the home's Zestimate still showed about $1.75 million, a gap of roughly 40%, as Inman reported at the time. Zillow's economists explained that the model struggled with that home's odd-shaped lot, its location on a busy road, and the luxury price range. That's the point: those are exactly the details a person notices in five minutes and a model can miss entirely.
2. Zillow stopped buying homes because its pricing missed. In 2021, Zillow was making cash offers on homes using its own pricing models. It shut that business down that November, taking a write-down of about $304 million in one quarter for homes it had bought for more than it expected to sell them for, and cutting about a quarter of its staff. CEO Rich Barton told investors the company had been "unable to predict future pricing of homes" accurately enough to make it a safe business.
3. Homeowners sued, and the courts sided with Zillow. Illinois homeowners sued Zillow in 2017, arguing that Zestimates were often inaccurate and hard to get corrected. The case was dismissed, and in 2019 a federal appeals court agreed: Zillow is clear that the Zestimate is an estimate, not an appraisal.
To be fair to Zillow, it says exactly that on its own site. The Zestimate is a free starting point, and it has gotten more accurate over the years. The trouble starts when people treat it as a price.
Who gets frustrated, and why
Sellers. A high Zestimate becomes the number you "have to get." When the market doesn't agree, the house sits, and the price cuts start. A low Zestimate does the opposite damage: some owners decide they can't afford to move and never call anyone.
Buyers. Buyers sometimes print a Zestimate to justify a lower offer, or assume a house is a bargain because it's listed under its estimate. Neither one tells you what the house will appraise for or what it's actually worth to the next buyer.
Agents. Plenty of listing appointments start with a seller defending a website's number. A good agent's job isn't to argue with the website. It's to show you the sales that matter.
What the market is actually doing in New Castle County
Here's why pricing judgment matters right now. In October 2026, among single-family homes and townhomes in New Castle County:
- The average home sold for 97.7% of its original list price, down from 98.1% a year earlier. The median was 99.1%.
- 28.5% of homes sold above their final list price, down from 32.7% in October 2025.
- 43.4% sold below their final list price, up from 34.6% a year earlier.
Those list prices were set by people who walked through the homes and studied the comps, and still more than 4 in 10 homes sold under list. A model that has never been inside the house is working with even less information.
Source: Bright MLS, data pulled Nov 15, 2026. Single-family homes and townhomes (twins excluded). Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
What to trust instead
- Closed sales near you. Homes like yours that actually sold in the last three to six months, close by. Not active listings, and not what a neighbor says they're asking.
- Condition and updates. A new roof, an updated kitchen, a finished basement, or a house that needs work. Public records often miss all of it.
- The street, not the ZIP code. A busy road, a backyard that faces a highway, a cul-de-sac lot. Buyers pay for these differences, and estimates often blur them.
- This month's market. In a market where inventory is rising, the first two weeks on the market matter more than ever. Price it right from day one.
If you're buying, the appraisal is what your lender relies on, and appraisers base value on comparable sales and their own inspection of the home.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is my Zestimate different from what homes are selling for?
A Zestimate relies mainly on public records, past sales, and home facts. It can miss updates that were never reported, the home's condition, and location details like a busy road or an unusual lot. Recent nearby closed sales usually tell you more.
Did Zillow's CEO really sell his home for less than its Zestimate?
Yes. In 2016, then-CEO Spencer Rascoff sold a Seattle home for $1.05 million. Its Zestimate the day after the sale was about $1.75 million, roughly 40% higher. Zillow said the home's unusual lot and busy-road location made it hard for the model to value.
Why did Zillow stop buying houses?
In November 2021, Zillow shut down its home-buying business, Zillow Offers, after taking a write-down of about $304 million in one quarter on homes it bought for more than it expected to sell them for. Its CEO said the company couldn't predict home prices accurately enough to make the business safe.
Is a Zestimate the same as an appraisal?
No. Zillow says the Zestimate is not an appraisal, and a federal appeals court agreed in 2019. An appraisal is done by a licensed appraiser who inspects the home and analyzes comparable sales.
How many homes in New Castle County sell over asking price?
In October 2026, 28.5% of single-family homes and townhomes in New Castle County sold above their final list price and 43.4% sold below it, according to Bright MLS data.
The Bottom Line
A Zestimate is a starting point, and even Zillow says so. When it's time to make a real decision, you want the sales that actually compare to your home and someone who has seen it in person.
Want the real numbers for your house? Send me your address and I'll send you a pricing range plus the 3 comparable sales that matter most. Text me at (302) 613-4228. You can also request your free Home Equity Report — it'll show you your home's current value, how much equity you've built, and what's happening with prices and inventory right in your neighborhood. Get your free report at search.teamsordelet.com/seller.
Team Sordelet and David Sordelet are licensed real estate professionals, not attorneys, accountants, or financial advisors. This article is general information, not legal, tax, or financial advice. Every situation is different — consult a qualified attorney, CPA, or lender about your specific circumstances before making decisions.
About David Sordelet
Looking for a trusted real estate professional in Delaware or Maryland who can help you make smart choices? Look no further than David Sordelet, Designated Broker of Real Broker Delaware and Team Leader of Team Sordelet.
With over two decades of experience, 1,000+ successful transactions, and 200+ five-star client reviews, David is recognized as one of the region's leading real estate experts. As the Designated Broker in Delaware and a licensed agent in Maryland, he provides unmatched knowledge of Wilmington, Newark, Hockessin, Dover, Middletown, and the Maryland Eastern Shore.
David understands that in real estate, who you work with matters most. That's why he combines personalized service, clear communication, and expert negotiation with the most modern marketing strategies and cutting-edge technology to achieve exceptional results for his clients.
Whether you're a first-time homebuyer, a move-up family, an investor, or a seller looking to maximize value, David Sordelet is the proven real estate professional you can count on.
Licensed in Delaware (RB-0031238) and Maryland (5013138). Team Sordelet of Real Broker, LLC, 1400 Peoples Plaza, Suite 110, Newark, DE 19702.